Constant Comments
Success is not final, failure is not fatal: it is the courage to continue that counts.Success is not final, failure is not fatal; it is the courage to continue that counts. — Anonymous
A nation of sheep will beget a government of wolves. — Edward R. Murrow
Publisher & Editor: Marie Burns
I have a Bluesky account now. The URL is https://bsky.app/profile/marie-burns.bsky.social . When Reality Chex goes down, check my Bluesky page for whatever info I am able to report on the status of Reality Chex. If you can't access the URL, I found that I could Google Bluesky and ask for Marie Burns. Google will include links to accounts for people whose names are, at least in part, Maria Burns, so you'll have to tell Google you looking only for Marie.
The Commentariat -- March 9
** The Terrorists I Love by Peter King.... Scott Shane of the New York Times: Rep. "Peter T. King, whose House committee is holding hearings on the radicalization of American Muslims, once fervently supported a terrorist group, the Irish Republican Army."
Janet Hook of the Wall Street Journal: "Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D., Nev.) said that efforts to bridge the parties' $50 billion difference in proposed budget cuts for the remainder of fiscal-year 2011 could reach beyond domestic discretionary spending and move into tax policy and programs such as farm subsidies." ...
... Good Luck with That. Julie Hirschfeld Davis and Heidi Przybyla of Bloomberg News: "Almost 8 in 10 people say Republicans and Democrats should reach a compromise on a plan to reduce the federal budget deficit to keep the government running, a Bloomberg National Poll shows. At the same time, lopsided margins oppose cuts to Medicare, education, environmental protection, medical research and community-renewal programs." ...
... AND Harry Reid gets it really wrong on repeal of an aspect of healthcare reform. This is a little wonkish, but Harry's bright idea -- borrowed from House Republicans -- could end up costing you a bundle. Ezra Klein has a detailed explanation.
Glenn Greenwald on President Obama's indefinite detention policy for terror suspects incarcerated at Guantanamo Bay: "... Obama -- for reasons having nothing to do with Congress -- worked from the start to preserve the crux of the Bush/Cheney detention regime." ...
... Dafna Linzer of ProPublica: "Obama said he remained committed to closing the prison, a pledge he made on his first full day in office. That pledge, enshrined in his first executive order, was widely seen as a repudiation of the detention system his predecessor built. But the new order suggests that Obama's original pledge was more about dismantling a facility than a system."
David Nakamura of the Washington Post: "Spurred by memories of the World War II-era roundup and internment of 110,000 of their own people, Japanese Americans, especially on the West Coast, have been among the most vocal and passionate supporters of embattled Muslims. They've rallied public support against hate crimes at mosques, signed on to legal briefs opposing the indefinite detention of Muslims by the government, organized cross-cultural trips to the Manzanar internment camp memorial in California and held 'Bridging Communities' workshops in Islamic schools and on college campuses."
Ezra Klein wrote a post on Sunday briefly noting a book by Ed Glaeser titled The Triumph of the City. Based on his reading, Klein concluded,
... cities make us smarter, more productive and more innovative. To put it plainly, they make us richer. And the evidence in favor of this point is very, very strong. But it would of course be political suicide for President Obama to say that part of winning the future is ending the raft of subsidies we devote to sustaining rural living. And the U.S. Senate is literally set up to ensure that such a policy never becomes politically plausible. ...
... So Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack gave Klein a call to say he took the post as "a slam on rural America." Vilsack says farmers deserve subsidies because they're "good and hardworking people." Klein says his suburban parents are "good, hardworking people, too," but they're not getting equivalent subsidies. Klein provides a transcript of their conversation. I would say Klein gets the better of Vilsack. Of course, it's Klein's post. ...
... Speaking of farm subsidies, Sam Stein reports that at least three of those "good, hardworking" Republican Wisconsin state senators who plan to vote for some enforced belt-tightening for Wisconsin public workers receive substantial federal farm subsidies. CW: this of course follows the Republican political policy: "Slash spending unless it's spending for me."
On the Senate floor, ConservaDem Sen. Joe Manchin (WV) criticizes President Obama for not leading on the budget battle. Politico story by Jennifer Epstein & Scott Wong here:
Jay Newton-Small of Time loves cowboy poetry. But maybe not as much as Sen. Majority Leader Harry Reid loves cowboy poetry.
Right Wing World
It's the Media's Fault. Mike Joyella of Mediaite: "Potential GOP presidential candidate Mike Huckabee has more to say about Natalie Portman and the president’s roots in Kenya. For better or worse." With audio.
Shit Happens When You Work So Hard for America. There’s no question at times of my life, partially driven by how passionately I felt about this country, that I worked far too hard and things happened in my life that were not appropriate. Newt Gingrich to CBN's David Brody on why he had extra-marital affairs. Watch on an empty stomach:
There was a Congressional Research Service report that just was issued in February, and we discovered that secretly, unbeknownst to members of Congress, over $105 billion was hidden in the 'Obamacare' legislation to fund the implementation of 'Obamacare'. This is something that wasn't known. This money was broken up, hidden in various parts of the bill. -- Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-Minn.), March 6, 2011
This is a crime against democracy. No one knew that Harry Reid, [Nancy] Pelosi and Obama put $105 billion in spending in the bill. ... This is a bombshell. -- Bachmann, March 8, 2011
There is no 'bombshell' except Bachmann's bombast. She is correct that Congress already has appropriated some spending in future years, but her claim that this money was "hidden" does not have credibility. The money for these programs was clearly described and analyzed by the Congressional Budget Office before the legislation was voted into law. -- Glenn Kessler, the Washington Post Fact-Checker
Wingers Fall Out of Love with Sarah Palin. Noreen Malone of The New Republic has the details.
Local News
Lizette Alvarez of the New York Times: "The Florida Legislature, convening its 60-day session on Tuesday, quickly set its sights on measures that would link the pay of new teachers to student performance and allow school boards to fire teachers more easily for mediocre results. The final bill is expected to clear the Legislature next week. Unlike last year, when similar legislation was vetoed by the former governor, who considered it too extreme, this slightly softened version is expected to win Gov. Rick Scott’s approval easily. The far-reaching bills ... would position Florida as a leader among those states taking on teachers’ unions." ...
... Disenfranchising Democrats. Peter Wallsten: Florida Repubicans are set to roll back voting rights for ex-felons. Because, guess what? -- A lot of them are black & they'll vote for Obama. ...
... Jeff Burlew of the Tallahassee Democrat: "A state Senate committee is set to hear Sen. Greg Evers' bill today that would allow guns to be carried openly by people with concealed-weapon licenses. The proposal also would allow guns on state university campuses, where they're currently banned. Last month, Robert Cowie of Orange Park, the father of Ashley Cowie, a Florida State University student killed Jan. 9 in an apparent rifle accident at an off-campus fraternity house, urged lawmakers not to push forward with the bill." Here's video of Dr. Cowie's testimony, which is heartbreaking:
... Miami Herald Update: "The NRA was handed a rare defeat Wednesday when Senate Republicans scrapped plans to allow some people to bring guns on college campuses. The defeat was born of a tragic frat house shooting at Florida State University on Jan. 9." CW: this is very good news, but it is not a lesson in the glory of democracy. The Herald story goes on to report that Cowie is a close friend of "one of the most powerful members of the Senate, John Thrasher, R-St. Augustine. As Rules Committee chairman, he wields considerable influence over which bills can reach the full floor of the Senate for a vote."
News Ledes
** Chicago Sun-Times: "Acting on perhaps the most significant issue he will ever face, [Illinois] Gov. [Pat] Quinn Wednesday signed landmark legislation to repeal the state’s 'seriously broken' death penalty and then commuted the death sentences of the 15 men on Death Row."
** New York Times: Wisconsin "Republicans voted to strip collective bargaining rights from public workers after discovering a way to bypass the [senate] chamber’s missing Democrats." ..
... Milwaukee Journal Sentinel: "Senate Minority Leader Mark Miller (D-Monona) said Democrats who have been boycotting the Senate for three weeks would return to Wisconsin once the bill passes the Assembly...." ...
... Wisconsin State Journal: "Gov. Scott Walker has offered to remove limits on wage negotiations and keep some other collective bargaining rights for public employees, according to e-mails his office exchanged with one of the 14 Democratic senators.... The e-mails were released by the governor's office Tuesday afternoon following public records requests from media outlets. The proposed changes, which also would allow collective bargaining for employees of the UW Hospital and Clinics to remain, are only a 'starting point' for reaching an agreement on the bill, said state Sen. Bob Jauch, D-Poplar."
Washington Post: "David S. Broder, 81, a Pulitzer Prize-winning columnist for The Washington Post and one of the most respected writers on national politics for four decades, died Wednesday at Capital Hospice in Arlington of complications from diabetes."
AP: "Muslim-Christian clashes in the Egyptian capital Cairo have killed 11 people and wounded more than 90, security and hospital officials said on Wednesday. The clashes broke out Tuesday night when a Muslim mob attacked thousands of Christians protesting against the burning of a Cairo church last week."
Washington Post: "The United States and its European allies are considering the use of naval assets to deliver humanitarian aid to Libya and to block arms shipments to the government of Moammar Gaddafi, even as they weigh the legality of imposing a no-fly zone without United Nations authorization, according to U.S. and European officials."
Reuters: "The Obama administration on Tuesday appealed a judge's ruling in Florida that struck down its landmark healthcare overhaul law as unconstitutional because it required Americans to buy healthcare insurance or face a penalty."
International Women's Day
Let's see how the United States is celebrating International Women's Day:
Fox Los Angeles. Here at home, "First Lady Michelle Obama and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton marked the 100th anniversary of International Women's Day Wednesday by honoring 10 women from around the world with awards that recognize efforts they have made to further women's rights. During the 2011 Women of Courage Awards ceremony held at the State Department, Clinton called recipient of this year's awards 'remarkable,' while Obama lauded it as the 'one of the most important' events she will attend."...
... Also speaking at the ceremony, Prime Minister Julia Gillard of Australia and, get this, Goldman Sachs CEO Lloyd Blankfein. Here's the reason for Blankfein's presence: he's going to spend a few bucks on the ladies. The State Department readout is here. Here's Clinton's speech:
... No mention in the official transcript of this exchange, supplied by Binoy Kampmark in Counterpunch:
The real interest came after the sugary, salutary speeches were concluded. Questions asked of Undersecretary for Public Diplomacy and Public Affairs Judith McHale, Assistant Secretary of Education Ann Stock and Clinton’s own chief of staff Cheryl Mills caught them off guard. A Latin American woman (Voice of America News remains, as ever, generic) questioned whether the United States was even ready for a female president. Mills answered that the country was ‘more than willing to support women in a leadership role and more than willing to actually see a woman as their leader’ though she had to admit that ‘that final hurdle’ had to be crossed.
Michelle Obama spoke late this afternoon at the White House:
Not enough? It's better than what's happening elsewhere:
Nicholas Kristof: "Bangladesh has a woman prime minister, Sheikh Hasina, who has done nothing much for women – and who now is pursuing a campaign of vilification against Muhammad Yunus, the Nobel Peace Prize winner who has been a champion of impoverished women all around the globe.... It’s astonishing – and so disappointing – to see a woman prime minister who does nothing for her country’s women go after a man who has devoted his life to helping the neediest women. And it’s a reminder that the struggle to achieve gender equality is not a battle between the sexes, but something far more subtle. It’s often about misogyny and paternalism, but those are values that are absorbed and transmitted almost as much by women as by men."
Julie Ioffe in Slate: "Today is the 100th anniversary of International Women’s Day, the brainchild of socialist feminists at the turn of the 20th century. The idea was to give women a day to come together and push for equal rights. Though it isn’t really celebrated in the United States, many countries continue to mark the date with an official public holiday. Here in Russia, it is a major holiday with its own long weekend.... March 8 has become a travesty in modern Russia. In the 20 years since the fall of the Soviet Union, Russia has quickly shed all vestiges of egalitarianism and become ensconced in a deeply patriarchal social order."
Washington Post: Egypt. "According to Twitter reports from Cairo, a march planned for Tahrir Square in honor of the 100th anniversary of International Women's Day was met by an even larger crowd of men deriding the women for being there and harassing them." ...
... Jenna Krajeski has a first-hand account of the strife in Tahrir Square. She concludes, "Mubarak is gone. Misogyny might be a tougher foe."
Tristan McConnell of Global Post: "In Sudan 60 women gathered on a busy street in Omdurman to protest against rape and rights abuses only to find themselves surrounded by 250 police. Ten minutes of chanting and banner waving was all the security men could bear before they quickly arrested half the women and threw them into a truck. The detained women continued to shout slogans so some of the men gave them a beating with sticks for good measure."
David Smith of the Guardian: "Marches by thousands of women in protest at Ivory Coast's president Laurent Gbagbo have ended in bloodshed after his army killed four people. The women made their stand on International Women's Day, less than a week after Gbagbo's soldiers killed seven women at a peaceful demonstration, earning worldwide condemnation. After a small women's march in the Treichville neighbourhood, one of several in Abidjan on Tuesday, security forces burst into the area and began shooting."
AOL News: the five worst countries to be born a woman. "Here are the five countries with the highest (that is, worst) scores on the 2008 Gender Inequality Index, the most recent ranking available": Yemen, Congo, Niger, Mali, Afghanistan.
The Commentariat -- March 8
More James O'Keefe Shenanigans. Michael Calderone of Yahoo News: "Former NPR executive Ron Schiller slams Republicans and the tea party movement and suggests that NPR would be better off without any federal funding in a hidden-camera video released Tuesday by conservative filmmaker James O'Keefe. Schiller, president of the NPR Foundation ... until just last week, appears on the tape at Georgetown's Café Milano with NPR director of institutional giving Betsy Liley and two men posing as executives from a fake Islamic organization considering a $5 million donation to the network.... 'We are appalled by the comments made by Ron Schiller in the video, which are contrary to what NPR stands for," said NPR spokeswoman Dana Davis Rehm in a statement." Includes O'Keefe's video. CW: frankly, Schiller got it mostly right.
David Sanger & Thom Shanker of the New York Times: "Nearly three weeks after Libya erupted in what may now turn into a protracted civil war, the politics of military intervention to speed the ouster of Col. Muammar el-Qaddafi grow more complicated by the day — for both the White House and Republicans."
Bush III. Dana Milbank: "Not only had [President Obama] revoked his pledge to close Gitmo within a year, but he also had contradicted his claim that a detention policy 'can't be based simply on what I or the executive branch decide alone.' His executive order did exactly what he said must not be done, in a style favored by his predecessor in the Oval Office."
** Nancy Gibbs of Time: "... the GOP spending bill does not only cut Planned Parenthood; it kills Title X, the 1970 law that provides family planning for nearly 5 million women every year at more than 4,600 health centers. The Guttmacher Institute estimates that for every dollar invested in Title X — specifically for contraceptive care — taxpayers save a little under $4 in Medicaid costs for mother and baby just in the first year. Title X prevents about a million unintended pregnancies annually, of which about half would likely end in abortion. Consistency is the true test of conviction; anything less is just prejudice dressed up as principle. If pro-life lawmakers kill Title X, they need to accept either the risk of increasing the abortion rate or the cost of growing numbers of children born to poor parents. Their plan also cuts money for prenatal care and slices $750 million for nutrition for mothers and infants."
Walter Shapiro in Politics Daily: "After ignoring the deficit for almost a decade, the new orthodoxy is that Medicare and Social Security must be revamped immediately because 2075 is getting closer every day. With a series of artificial deadlines coming up (March 18 for funding the government and sometime later this spring for raising the statutory debt ceiling), congressional Republicans and the Obama White House are giving lip service to fantasies about long-term fixes. Even if it would not jeopardize the fragile recovery, this is the wrong medicine at the wrong time."
The New York Times Editorial Board: "On Thursday, Representative Peter King, the chairman of the House Homeland Security Committee, is scheduled to open a series of hearings that seem designed to stoke fear against American Muslims. His refusal to tone down the provocation despite widespread opposition suggests that he is far more interested in exploiting ethnic misunderstanding than in trying to heal it." ...
... Jonathan Allen & Jake Sherman of Politico: "The top two House Republican leaders are divided over how to handle the bubbling controversy surrounding Homeland Security Chairman Peter King’s hearing into “radicalization” in the American Muslim community. Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-Va.), the highest-ranking Jewish member of Congress, is squarely behind King.... 'Chairman King is chairman of the Homeland Security Committee' is all [Speaker John] Boehner spokesman Michael Steel would say when asked about the controversy. [Majority Whip Kevin] McCarthy’s office declined to comment." ...
... Bob Herbert says of the King hearings, "America should be better than this. We’ve had all the requisite lessons: Joe McCarthy, the House Un-American Activities Committee, the demonization of blacks and Jews, the internment of Japanese-Americans, and on and on and on. It’s such a tired and ugly refrain." ...
... Karen Garcia sees King's hearings as part of the Republican scare tactics designed to defeat President Obama in 2012. (He is a Muslim, you know.) Garcia thinks if President Obama quit playing by Republican rules and showed he was a Democrat by going to Wisconsin to stand with the unions, the press wouldn't have time to concentrate on King's little melodrama. ...
... Gene Robinson: "King seems untroubled that the freedoms of religion and association are guaranteed by the Constitution. His public exercise in Islamophobia ... can do no good -- and much harm."
Even the UK is noticing King. You can vote here in the Guardian on whether you think King's hearings are legitimate or "a fear-mongering witchhunt." At the time I voted, 69.3% went with witchhunt.
Goldman Sachs-Government Partnership (Is Not What You're Thinking). Jia Lin Yang of the Washington Post: "To give women [in developing countries] a boost, Goldman Sachs and the State Department are teaming up to offer classes on the basics of business management to help these women drive economic growth in their communities. The partnership, which will be announced Tuesday by Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton and Goldman's chief executive Lloyd Blankfein, augments an existing program run by Goldman's charitable arm that has so far educated more than 3,500 women in more than 20 countries, including Afghanistan, Rwanda and China."
President Obama & Prime Minister Gillard visit Wakefield High in Arlington, Virginia. PM Gillard takes questions from students:
Right Wing World
Clarence Thomas Has a Louis XIV Moment. Jonathan Turley in a Los Angeles Times op-ed: "Thomas appears to have finally merged his own personality with the institution [i.e., the Supreme Court] itself. Thus, any criticism — even criticism that he is harming the court — is an attack on the institution. It is more than an embarrassing conceit; it can be a dangerous delusion for any justice."
"The Enema Man & Snoopy, Snoopy Poop Dogg." Grumpy Grampy Alan Simpson of Catfood Commission fame. Politico has an item here, but the video is priceless:
Local News
Rick Scott Is Not a Constitution-Loving Teabagger. Lizette Alvarez & Gary Fineout of the New York Times: "In his first two months in office, the governor has irritated the [Florida] State Senate’s powerful Budget Committee chairman, [a fellow-Republican,] by selling two state jets without legislative permission, a constitutional no-no.... He annoyed the ambitious Senate president, [also a Republican], as well as a host of leaders in conservative states, by trying to kill off a database to track the fraudulent distribution of addictive prescription drugs before it was up and running. He did so without consulting lawmakers...." ...
It’s necessary at this time, I think — because our governor’s new — to let him know this is not a monarchy. He’s not a king. This is a democracy. -- Arthenia L. Joyner, a Democratic Florida State Senator
News Ledes
CBS News: Rep. Peter King, who will hold hearings beginning Thursday on home-grown Muslim terror threats, has been getting threats of his own & will receive stepped-up security.
President Obama visited a classroom in Boston, Massachusetts, & made remarks this afternoon. New York Times item here. Update: here's the Times' post-visit story.
AP: "Libyan warplanes launched at least five new airstrikes Tuesday near rebel positions in the oil port of Ras Lanouf, keeping up a counteroffensive to prevent the opposition from advancing toward leader Moammar Gadhafi's stronghold in the capital Tripoli." ...
... Washington Post: "The Libyan opposition said an offer -- purportedly from Gaddafi -- had been conveyed to council elders late Monday in the provisional capital of Benghazi. According to an opposition spokesman, the Libyan leader would agree to step down if granted immunity from prosecution and safe passage out of the country. But opposition officials said they were still trying to establish the veracity of the offer, which came from Jadallah Azous al-Talhi, a former minister in Gaddafi's government."
AP: "The U.S. military is too white and too male at the top and needs to change recruiting and promotion policies and lift its ban on women in combat, an independent report for Congress said Monday. Seventy-seven percent of senior officers in the active-duty military are white, while only 8 percent are black, 5 percent are Hispanic and 16 percent are women, the report by an independent panel said, quoting data from September 2008."