Constant Comments
Success is not final, failure is not fatal: it is the courage to continue that counts.Success is not final, failure is not fatal; it is the courage to continue that counts. — Anonymous
A nation of sheep will beget a government of wolves. — Edward R. Murrow
Publisher & Editor: Marie Burns
I have a Bluesky account now. The URL is https://bsky.app/profile/marie-burns.bsky.social . When Reality Chex goes down, check my Bluesky page for whatever info I am able to report on the status of Reality Chex. If you can't access the URL, I found that I could Google Bluesky and ask for Marie Burns. Google will include links to accounts for people whose names are, at least in part, Maria Burns, so you'll have to tell Google you looking only for Marie.
Briefly Noted
Mashup Extraordinaire. Five seconds of every No. 1 pop song from the 1950s to today, Part 1 & 2:
Five Seconds Of Every #1 Pop Single Part 1 by mjs538
Five Seconds Of Every #1 Pop Single Part 2 by mjs538
... Via Peter Finocchiaro of Salon.
The Commentariat -- February 24
Art by Thomas Porostocky.Russ Buettner of the New York Times: "... affidavits filed in a ... lawsuit reveal ... Roger E. Ailes, chairman of Fox News," was accused by his employee Judith Regan of encouraging her to lie to federal investigators who were vetting Bernie Kerik for secretary of Homeland Security. (Kerik, with whom Regan was having an affair, is now in jail, for -- among other things -- lying to White House officials.) "What is more, the documents say that Ms. Regan taped the telephone call from Mr. Ailes in which Mr. Ailes discusses her relationship with Mr. Kerik. It is unclear whether the existence of the tape played a role in News Corporation’s decision to move quickly to settle Ms. Regan’s lawsuit, paying her $10.75 million in a confidential settlement reached two months after she filed it in 2007."
Tom Shanker of the New York Times: Gen. David Petraeus, "the commander of American forces in Afghanistan, will order an investigation into allegations that military personnel were instructed to engage in 'information operations' to convince members of Congress to support the mission, officials said Thursday.... The investigation was prompted by an article released on Thursday by Rolling Stone magazine, which described an 'information operation' or 'psychological operation' ordered by Lt. Gen. William Caldwell, who is in charge of training Afghan security forces." ...
... Here's the article by Michael Hastings. Hastings won a George Polk award for his story on Gen. Stanley McChrystal. The upshot of Hastings' report was that President Obama relieved Gen. McChrystal of his command over Afghanistan operations.
Nick Timiraos, et al., of the Wall Street Journal: "The Obama administration is trying to push through a settlement over mortgage-servicing breakdowns that could force America's largest banks to pay for reductions in loan principal worth billions of dollars. Terms of the administration's proposal include a commitment from mortgage servicers to reduce the loan balances of troubled borrowers who owe more than their homes are worth...."
Ditching DOMA
Commentary:
... Andrew Cohen of The Atlantic: with "Ten Takeaways from Obama's DOMA Reversal": "... the real moving force here is U.S. District Judge Joseph Tauro. Last July, the Republican appointee, who is revered among federal judges, simply vitiated Section 3 of the DOMA in a ruling now on appeal to the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. When the Defense of Marriage Act finally falls, and it surely will, Judge Tauro's ruling will be seen as the turning point. Here, it gave great cover to the administration." ...
... Adam Serwer of the American Prospect: "This doesn't mean the law is defunct -- if the Supreme Court doesn't overturn it, or Congress doesn't pass legislation doing so, DOMA stays on the books." ...
... Lawrence O'Donnell speaks with Glenn Greenwald about the Administration's reversal:
... Greg Sargent: "After the President did the right thing and threw his weight behind the repeal of don't ask don't tell, many argued that his success on that front would only make his position on DOMA less tenable -- basic consistency would demand that his administration stop defending it in court.... The arc of history is bending -- albeit slowly -- in the right direction." ...
... And now for a word from Fox "News," courtesy of Igor Volsky of the Wonk Room: "Fox News invited the National Organization for Marriage (NOM)’s Maggie Gallagher to discuss the development. Gallagher, who’s organization has been spearheading the fight against marriage equality, chastised the president for declaring that 'gay is like black' and promised to 'push very hard' to urge the House of Representatives to defend the law in the administration’s stead." With video, if you'd really like to hear from Gallagher. ...
... Monica Crowley, also speaking on Fox "News" about the Obama Administration's decision, says the President is practicing "a form of dictatorship." That is "Mubarak Obama," says she. The video is here, wherein Lawrence O'Donnell explains why Crowley is an idiot.
The Backstory: "New York Times story here. AND here's the statement from the Department of Justice. AND here's AG Eric Holder's letter notifying Congress of the DOJ's change of position on DOMA.
Prof. Jeffrey Sachs does a nice job of summarizing billionaires'/Congress's attack on the middle class:
I campaigned on (the proposals in the budget repair bill for Wisconsin) all throughout the election. Anybody who says they are shocked on this has been asleep for the past two years. -- Scott Walker, February 21, 2011
... Walker, who offered many specific proposals during the campaign, did not go public with even the bare-bones of his multi-faceted plans to sharply curb collective bargaining rights. He could not point to any statements where he did. We could find none either. -- Politifact (Read their whole analysis.)
... More Fallout from the Prank Call. Mary Bottari of AlterNet: "... if [Walker] is choosing to lay off workers as a political tactic when he wasn’t otherwise planning to do so then it is not just morally repugnant but legally questionable. State and federal contract and labor law has protections against this type of abusive behavior and inappropriate quid pro quo." ...
... Faking a Budget Crisis. Tim Fernholz of the National Journal: "... while [Wisconsin Gov. Scott] Walker argues that his budget-repair legislation must be passed soon to avoid job cuts, the most controversial parts of his bill would have no immediate effect. The state’s entire budget shortfall for this year -- the reason that Walker has said he must push through immediate cuts -- would be covered by the governor's relatively uncontroversial proposal to restructure the state’s debt. By contrast..., his call to curtail the collective-bargaining rights of the state's public-employees, wouldn't save any money this year." ...
I spent a good deal of time overnight thinking about Governor Walker's response, during his news conference yesterday (Wednesday), to the suggestion that his administration ‘thought about' planting troublemakers among those who are peacefully protesting his bill. I would like to hear more of an explanation from Governor Walker as to what exactly was being considered, and to what degree it was discussed by his cabinet members. I find it very unsettling and troubling that anyone would consider creating safety risks for our citizens and law enforcement officers. -- Noble Wray, Chief of Police, Madison
... Monica Davey of the New York Times on life on the lam in Illinois for state legislators from Wisconsin & Indiana. ...
... Having It Both Ways. So now that Indiana legislators, at Republican Gov. Mitch Daniels' urging, have dropped their draconian bill to curb the bargaining union rights* of the state's public employees, Daniels gives a speech deriding the unions as "the privileged elite." What a shameful little turd.
* CW: this I didn't understand: six years ago, Daniels did end collective bargaining rights for Indiana public workers. Now he would like to further curb union rights, such as they are.
Andrew Solomon of the New Yorker on Libyan dictator Muammar Qaddifi's mistakes.
Eric Schmitt of the New York Times: Investigators are trying to determine what happened in the attempted rescue of American hostages whom Somali pirates subsequently murdered. Initial information "raises questions about the crucial decision [by a FBI negotiator] to detain the pirate leaders."
Elizabeth Harris of the New York Times writes an item on Donald Rumsfeld's appearance on "The Daily Show." CW: I can't stand to listen, & I just won't embed Rummy but the extended interview is here. After the interview, Rumsfeld tweeted, “Just wrapped up one of the most thoughtful interviews of book tour with @thedailyshow.”
If you have to take the U.S. citizenship test, give the answers the U.S. Citizenship & Immigration Services want, not the correct answers. CW: I took the test a while ago & found another incorrect answer which the writer of this piece, Dafna Linzer, doesn't mention.
Right Wing World
Alex Pareene of Salon: "In the parallel media universe of the right-wing blogosphere, this is the single biggest story of the week. Maybe the month, even. A union thug viciously attacked an innocent young woman, in broad daylight. And it's all on camera! Or, like, a guy pushed a camera that was six inches from his face, wielded by someone engaging him in a heated argument." With video of the "vicious thug," whom Freedom Works provoked in Washington, D.C., not Madison, Wisconsin. Pareene adds, "Because these people are completely fucking shameless, the woman from the video has compared herself to Lara Logan." CW: Yup. Provoking someone to push your camera away is just like getting gang-raped in Cairo.
Local News
Marc Lacey of the New York Times: "Arizona lawmakers are proposing a sweeping package of immigration restrictions.... Illegal immigrants would be barred from driving in the state, enrolling in school or receiving most public benefits. Their children would receive special birth certificates that would make clear that the state does not consider them Arizona citizens. Some of the bills, like those restricting immigrants’ access to schooling and right to state citizenship, flout current federal law and are being put forward to draw legal challenges in hopes that the Supreme Court might rule in the state’s favor."
News Ledes
Washington Post: "Fighting between Libyan opposition groups and government paramilitary forces moved closer to the capital, Tripoli, on Thursday, as residents braced for a potential push to oust Moammar Gaddafi's regime from the city." ...
... New York Times: "Forces loyal to Col. Muammar el-Qaddafi were reported to be striking back in several cites surrounding Tripoli on Thursday, as rebellion crept closer to the capital and defections of military officers multiplied."
New York Times: "After years of fighting for control of a prominent valley in the rugged mountains of eastern Afghanistan, the United States military has begun to pull back most of its forces from ground it once insisted was central to the campaign against the Taliban and Al Qaeda. The withdrawal from the Pech Valley, a remote region in Kunar Province, formally began on Feb. 15.... Afghan units will remain in the valley, a test of their military readiness."
Chickens. Washington Post: "With a political standoff over spending threatening to trigger a federal shutdown next week, Senate Democrats began drafting a plan Thursday to slice billions of dollars from domestic agency budgets over the next seven months, yielding to Republican demands to reduce the size of government this year."
AP: "A small earthquake has hit Hawaii, with a jolt felt across Honolulu." PROBABLY BECAUSE ...
... AP: "Hawaii Gov. Neil Abercrombie signed same-sex civil unions into law Wednesday, calling it 'a triumph for everyone' that gay and lesbian couples will have the same state rights as married partners."
New York Times: "A 20-year-old Saudi Arabian student living in Texas has been arrested by federal agents, who charged him with planning to build bombs for terror attacks in the United States.... According to an [FBI] affidavit..., the student, Khalid Ali-M Aldawsari, indicated in online research and in a journal that he was considering attacking the Dallas residence of former President George W. Bush as well as hydroelectric dams, nuclear power plants, nightclubs and the homes of soldiers who were formerly stationed at the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq."
Guardian: "Wikileaks founder Julian Assange is to be extradited to Sweden to face allegations of rape and sexual assault. Assange will appeal, his legal team confirmed. If this is unsuccessful, he will be extradited to Sweden in 10 days. Delivering his ruling at a hearing at Belmarsh magistrates court in London, the chief magistrate Howard Riddle systematically dismissed each of the defence's arguments against Assange's extradition." New York Times: "A British court on Thursday ordered Julian Assange, the WikiLeaks founder, to be extradited to Sweden to face accusations of sexual abuse. His lawyers have seven days to appeal the ruling and immediately indicated that they would [do] so."
"The Hostage Taker"
Starring John Boehner
In the Title Role
Gail Collins sees the House of Representatives as "the deranged Pomeranian that yelps and throws itself against the window and tears up the upholstery 24/7" in a remake of “The Dog Whisperer,” and the Senate as being "like a narcoleptic Great Dane you can hardly rouse for dinner." It appears my comment has been sent to the back of the bus, so here it is:
Actually, I think the House is acting a little more like the gang of bad guys in all those hostage-taker movies. I just looked at a list of the top-grossing hostage movies for the last 30 years, and I haven't seen one of them. Their hook is to scare you into thinking, "This could happen to me." Evidently the hook works because the movies worry me so much I avoid seeing them. Well, now I have to watch, because the House version has come to the New York Times' front page.
In the House reality movie, Speaker Boehner plays the part of the chief hostage-taker. Boehner tells his hostage -- played by President Obama -- he will only pass a continuing resolution for a whole two weeks IF the President agrees to institute the House's deep cuts on a pro-rated basis. The ransom for the two-week respite then is about $4 billion in cuts.
Meanwhile, hostage negotiator Harry Reid -- who, as you point out, is busy with other things -- sent out a spokesman to say Boehner's "reckless measure ... isn't going to fool anyone." (What? Do we need a reminder that a hostage-taker is a "reckless" person?) So Boehner, not to be outdone by the negotiator's slight, addressed Reid through his own spokesman: "It's up to Senator Reid to tell Americans what — if anything — he's willing to cut."
The plot twist in this nail-biter? It works a lot like the movies. In the movies, you worry it can happen to you. In the House reality movie, it does happen to you. We're all hostages.
I'd say the Hostage-in-Chief is counting on our sympathy. The hostage-taker had better watch out: the newly "beleaguered" Boehner has made himself the villain in this reality show, and the American people/hostages are not likely to take his side.